News Local European Court clears Cyprus, deems Turkey guilty in Güzelyurtlu case

European Court clears Cyprus, deems Turkey guilty in Güzelyurtlu case

The Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) delivered its final judgement in the Güzelyurtlu case on Tuesday, after holding initially both Nicosia and Ankara responsible for not cooperating to solve the murder case.

By 15 votes to two, the Court deemed that Cyprus had not violated Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights (right to life/investigation) and unanimously voted that there had been a violation of the Article by Turkey.

In January 2005 Elmas Güzelyurtlu, his wife Zerrin, and their daughter Eylül were shot dead on the Nicosia-Larnaca highway and after the incident, their killers fled back to the Turkish-occupied areas of Cyprus.

In its Chamber judgement of April 4, 2017, the Court stated that Cyprus and Turkey were obliged to cooperate effectively to facilitate an effective investigation, however neither government had been prepared to compromise and find middle ground.

On September 18, 2017, the Court accepted the requests of the governments of Cyprus and Turkey that the case be referred to the Grand Chamber. Today’s judgment is final.

According to an ECHR press release, the Court found that “Cyprus had done all that could reasonably have been expected of it to obtain the surrender/extradition of the suspects from Turkey, submitting “Red notice” requests to Interpol and, when this proved unsuccessful, extradition requests to Turkey.

“The Cypriot authorities could not be criticised for refusing to submit all the evidence and to transfer the proceedings to the authorities of the ‘TRNC’ or Turkey. That would have amounted to Cyprus waiving its criminal jurisdiction over a murder committed in its controlled area in favour of the courts of an unrecognised entity set up within its territory,” the Court deemed.

Regarding Turkey, the Court said that “it had not made the minimum effort required in the circumstances of the case. They had ignored Cyprus’s extradition requests, returning them without reply, contrary to their obligation under Article 2, read in the light of other international agreements, to cooperate by informing the requesting State of its decision and, in the case of rejection, to give reasons.”

The Court held that Turkey was to pay each applicant €8,500 in respect of non-pecuniary damage. It further awarded the applicants a combined sum of €10,000 in respect of costs and expenses.

Find the full decision here.

Read more:

https://in-cyprus.com/european-court-to-deliver-final-judgement-in-guzelyurtlu-case-next-week/

Top Stories

Malta and Cyprus will have Europe’s lowest Covid death rate, study finds

Malta and Cyprus will have the lowest death toll among European countries during the 'first wave' of the Covid-19 pandemic with 19 and 54...

All but one on private jets were medical cases, says ministry

All but one of the passengers who repatriated to Cyprus in private jets were patients who were being transferred from hospitals abroad, the permanent...

Heavy rain, hailstorm lash Nicosia (photos)

Heavy rain and hail lashed Nicosia around midday on Thursday, as the Met Office issued a yellow alert warning of thunderstorms. The alert is in...

Pass the salt: The minute details that helped Germany build virus defences

One January lunchtime in a car parts company, a worker turned to a colleague and asked to borrow the salt. As well as the saltshaker,...

Health Minister extends measures to contain coronavirus spread

The Health Minister, in a new decree, extended until April 30 measures already in force to contain the spread of coronavirus. According to the new...

Taste

Stuffed vine leaves without meat

(Dolmadakia gialantzi) Rinse the leaves and boil in salted water for approximately 10 minutes until soft. Drain and place in some cold water with ice...

Snails with tomato sauce

When the snails are ready, drain them. Fry the onions in the oil and once slightly brown, add the tomatoes. Stir until cooked well...

Sea bream with capers

Clean the sea bream well, add salt and pepper to them and brush them with olive oil. Mix the capers and parsley together as...

Halloumi bread

Sift the flour with the salt into a bowl and mix in the yeast and lemon rind. Make a well in the centre of...