in-cyprus Court rejects Turkish Cypriot's claim seeking property restitution

Court rejects Turkish Cypriot’s claim seeking property restitution

The Nicosia district court has rejected a Turkish Cypriot’s claim for restitution of his property in Lakatamia and compensation of  €1.6 m Phileleftheros reported on Tuesday.

The land was used for the construction of the Archangelos Michael (Agios Mammas) refugee settlement.

The plaintiff is an in-law of the late Turkish Cypriot leader Rauf Denktash and is major shareholder in a supermarket chain in the occupied areas. He is also known to illegally own Greek Cypriot property in the Turkish-held north and in one instance built a supermarket in Kyrenia.

In a ruling dated November 22, the president of the Nicosia District Court, judge Nicholas Santis rejected the lawsuit of Turkish Cypriot Salih Mehmet Salih, owner of  the land opposite Jumbo where the refugee settlement was built.

His lawyer Christos Triantafyllides had argued that the plaintiff’s rights had been breached and demand restitution of the property and compensation of his losses. The plaintiff stated that since 1974 he had ceased to be a resident of the areas controlled by the government of the Republic of Cyprus against his will.

His lawyer argued that the state should satisfy the claim of the plaintiff at least through the Custodian of Turkish Cypriot properties, as any other person using someone’s property would be obliged to do. He also stated that after the Turkish invasion, the Republic of Cyprus in 1983 had illegally built the refugee settlement on the land of the Turkish Cypriot without his consent and without payment or any compensation.

Subsequently, the Custodian of Turkish Cypriot properties had also acted under legislation which, according to the plaintiff, is contrary to the  Constitution and provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights.

Arguing on behalf of the Attorney General’s side, lawyer  E. Flourentzou, who represented the Republic, said the plaintiff had abandoned his property and as a result it had fallen under the custody of the Ministry of Interior under legislation that did not contravene the Constitution or the European Convention on Human Rights since it concerns limitation of rights  in the public interest for a limited period of time, based on legislation that had been adopted to deal with the adverse situation in the Republic due to the invasion.

In addition, any claims made by the plaintiff’, including his claims for compensation, can only be satisfied after normalisation of the situation. The property ownership can be reconsidered and the property can be returned only in exceptional cases prior to the expiration of the existing law.

In his testimony, Salih Mehmet Salih admitted that in exchange for property in the government controlled areas, he received property belonging to Greek Cypriots in the occupied areas. Moreover, although he initially denied his involvement in the supermarket business in the occupied areas, eventually he admitted that on one occasion he built a supermarket in Kyrenia on the plot which belongs to the Greek Cypriot.

The court ultimately rejected his testimony as unreliable.

The court concluded that the plaintiff failed to prove the unconstitutional status of the law on the Custodian of Turkish Cypriot property and also failed to prove his case and in particular his claim for compensation of €1,603,921 for the period 1974 – 2010.

It is noted that the settlement was built in 1980 – 1983 and consists of 66 residential units, nine of which extend to another plot.


Top Stories

WHO reports record daily increase in global coronavirus cases

The World Health Organization reported a record increase in global coronavirus cases on Sunday, with the total rising by 230,370 in 24 hours. The biggest...

Seven new Covid-19 cases on Sunday

  Seven people have tested positive for coronavirus after 1176 tests, the Health Ministry said on Sunday. Five of the new cases were detected from 301...

Nicosia: Biker in critical condition after collision

  A 19 year old biker is in critical condition in hospital after his bike was involved in a collision with a car on Nicosia's...

Yellow alert for third day in a row

  The heat wave is set to continue tomorrow, with the Met Office issuing yet another extreme high temperature warning -- the third in a...

Any prospects for resumption of Cyprus talks would require termination of Turkish provocations

    Any prospects for the resumption of UN-led talks for a settlement to the Cyprus problem would require the termination of the Turkish provocative violations...


Kolokasi (Taro Root)

Ingredients: (Serves 4) 1 kg kolokasi (taro) root ½ kg pork (lean belly pork or shoulder) cut into large cubes 6 tbsp olive oil 1 head of fresh celery,...


Moungra is a traditional Cypriot mezze which consists in cauliflower pickled in fermented bread dough and typically served as an appetizer or meze. It...

Cheesy Eggplant Rolls

Ingredients 4 Eggplants 2 tbsp olive oil 1 chopped onion, 2 grated carrots 1 garlic clove (sliced) ¾ of the cup finely chopped canned tomato, ½ ts sugar 1 ts oregano 2 tbsp...

Black eyed peas with chard (Louvia me laxana)

Ingredients: 2 cups black eyed peas small lemon (juice) + 1 tsp lemon zest 1 bunch Cypriot chards olive oil & lemon for serving salt & pepper Method: Step 1 Put the...