Insider Business Administrative Court revokes Alpha Bank Cyprus fine

Administrative Court revokes Alpha Bank Cyprus fine

The Administrative Court has revoked a fine on Alpha Bank Cyprus by the Consumers Protection Service over misleading practices in regard to unfair terms. The €250,000 fine concerned housing loans and the Court’s judgment was issued on November 15.

The Service had argued that the calculation of the fine was based on financial statements for the year 2007 and 2015 of the complainants. And that it had called on the Bank to terminate the ongoing practices and not to repeat them in the future.

However, the Bank appealed the Service’s decision on various grounds and has subsequently succeeded in annulling it.

Justifying the annulment of the original decision the Administrative Court said, inter alia: “The Director of the Consumers Protection Service was not independent and impartial at the time”. And that the “excessive” decision was an abuse of power and the result of a lack of due diligence as well as insufficient or in any way lawful justification of the contested act.

In relation to the fine, the Court argued that the decision was unjustified and that the principle of proportionality had been infringed.

In addition, the Court stated that the Director’s failure to make a proper assessment of the nature of the complainants as consumers (which was strongly contested by the Bank) and the failure to carry out proper investigations led to the annulment of the original decision.

The Administrative Court concludes that the reason for the annulment of the original decision is due to a lack of arguments but also due to a misleading and vague statement of reasoning.

Therefore, the Administrative Court ruled in favour of the Bank and against the complainants at the cost of €1600 plus VAT.

By George Pyrishis

Top Stories

Britain says: Russia trying to hack and steal Covid-19 vaccine data

Britain's National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC) has reported that hackers backed by the Russian state are trying to steal treatment research pertaining to Covid-19...

Wanted for breaking and entering and theft (see images)

Police are looking for the person depicted in the photos, in the context of the investigation of a case of burglary and theft, an...

A controlled return to sports post-quarantine for fans…

A lengthy announcement has been issued by the Ministry of Health, which includes all the instructions in view of the new season in sports....

Clarifications over pandemic’s state of play in breakaway North Cyprus

The Greek-Cypriot side will ask for clarifications and information on four issues during the upcoming meeting of the bi-communal Technical Committee for Health which...

Weddings on hold, professional event planners in despair

The Pancyprian Association of Professional Events (PASYEPEK) demands that the holding of open weddings, baptisms and other events without restrictions be re-instated again starting...

Taste

Halloumi cheese fingers

Ingredients Serves: 2 1/2 tablespoon olive oil 175g (6 oz) halloumi cheese, cut into sticks 1 dessertspoon lemon juice 1/4 teaspoon dried oregano freshly ground black pepper to taste Method Prep:5min ›...

Koupes (cracked wheat pies) with mushrooms

Ingredients: For the dough: 1½ cup bulgur wheat 2 cups water 1 tsp. salt For the filling: 250gr. mushrooms, finely chopped ½ cup of olive oil 2 big onions, coarsely chopped 1...

Fried zucchini balls with halloumi

Ingredients: 6 medium zucchinis (approximately 1kg) 1 small onion, grated 1 large halloumi (about 250gr.), grated ½ cup simple flour 2 tsps. fine lemon zest 2 big eggs 1 tbsp. fresh...

Rocket salad

Ingredients: 4 cups rocket leaves, rinsed and dried 1 cup cherry tomatoes 1 cup pomegranate seeds 1 red bell pepper ½ cup croutons 2-3 light cheese slices (grated) salt ½ of a...