Insider Business Administrative Court revokes Alpha Bank Cyprus fine

Administrative Court revokes Alpha Bank Cyprus fine

The Administrative Court has revoked a fine on Alpha Bank Cyprus by the Consumers Protection Service over misleading practices in regard to unfair terms. The €250,000 fine concerned housing loans and the Court’s judgment was issued on November 15.

The Service had argued that the calculation of the fine was based on financial statements for the year 2007 and 2015 of the complainants. And that it had called on the Bank to terminate the ongoing practices and not to repeat them in the future.

However, the Bank appealed the Service’s decision on various grounds and has subsequently succeeded in annulling it.

Justifying the annulment of the original decision the Administrative Court said, inter alia: “The Director of the Consumers Protection Service was not independent and impartial at the time”. And that the “excessive” decision was an abuse of power and the result of a lack of due diligence as well as insufficient or in any way lawful justification of the contested act.

In relation to the fine, the Court argued that the decision was unjustified and that the principle of proportionality had been infringed.

In addition, the Court stated that the Director’s failure to make a proper assessment of the nature of the complainants as consumers (which was strongly contested by the Bank) and the failure to carry out proper investigations led to the annulment of the original decision.

The Administrative Court concludes that the reason for the annulment of the original decision is due to a lack of arguments but also due to a misleading and vague statement of reasoning.

Therefore, the Administrative Court ruled in favour of the Bank and against the complainants at the cost of €1600 plus VAT.

By George Pyrishis

Top Stories

Coronavirus: 109 new cases, two deaths on Tuesday

The Health Ministry on Tuesday announced the death of two people in Cyprus due to Covid-19. This raises the Mediterranean island’s death toll from the...

Health Minister to announce process of covid measures relaxation on Wednesday

Health Minister Constantinos Ioannou on Wednesday will announce the way the strict coronavirus measures now in effect in Cyprus will be gradually relaxed after...

Scientists in Greece find 20 million year-old petrified tree

Greek scientists on the volcanic island of Lesbos say they have found a rare fossilized tree whose branches and roots are still intact after...

Turkey bans parties at ski resorts after Covid curfew backlash

Turkey has banned music and parties at ski resorts after footage of crowded party scenes provoked anger in a country which has endured two months...

EMGF Agreement set to be ratified on Thursday

The House Foreign Affairs Committee on Tuesday decided to speed up the ratification of the Intergovernmental Agreement on the Statute of the East Mediterranean...

Taste

Squash soup

Ingredients: 1 kg pumpkin, cut into small cubes, approximately 5 cups 2 medium (400g) sweet potatoes, cut into cubes, approximately 2 ½ cups 1 chopped leek, only...

Mezedes

No visit to Cyprus is complete without enjoying the traditional meal of many small dishes known as ‘meze’. This large feast, which has been a...

Prawns with fried cheese, barley shaped pasta

Put the barley shaped pasta into a small pan with salted water, bring to a boil and when tender, drain. Peal the prawns leaving...

Salmon and shrimp sheftalies

Mix all ingredients for tabbouli in a bowl and keep to one side so flavours can combine. Prepare the sheftalies: wash and soak the casing...