World Cup 2018 A first for the world cup: Second looks

A first for the world cup: Second looks

Few topics generate as much discussion during the World Cup as the quality of the referees. He was offside! That should be a penalty kick! Does this guy even know the rules? But this year, video replay will be used to assist match officials at the World Cup. Here is how the video assistant referee system (VAR) is designed to work.

What gets reviewed?

The goal is not to second-guess every call but to avoid the most egregious errors, iconic mistakes like Diego Maradona’s Hand of God goal in 1986 or obvious blunders like the Carlos Tevez’s offside goal against Mexico in 2010. For that reason, video reviews are limited to four areas that are considered game-changing situations: goals, penalties, red cards and mistaken identity.

Who will be reviewing plays, and where?

The referee on the field remains the primary arbiter of all decisions, but now he will be backstopped by a team of colleagues. The first look goes to a video assistant referee and a team of three assistants watching each game from a central location in Moscow. These teams, which are big enough to include built-in redundancies, will be made up of 13 designated FIFA match officials.

Can the VAR stop play?

No. He can alert the on-field referee to a “clear and obvious” error if he sees one, but the incident cannot be addressed until the next stoppage in play. But soccer players, like NFL quarterbacks, are growing wise to this and quickly restarting play if they think the VAR is checking a decision. And as in American football, once the game moves on, there is no going back.

When will the referee rely on the VAR’s word?

In an effort to keep interruptions in play to a minimum, the on-field referee can trust the VAR on decisions that are clear to the naked eye on second look:

— A clear offside that leads to a goal or penalty kick.

— A ball that went out of play before a score or penalty kick.

— Whether a foul was committed inside or outside the penalty area.

When will referees use a field-level monitor to check for themselves?

The referee can review anything on a sideline monitor but in most leagues with VAR they usually save those trips for closer calls like these:

— Did an attacking player commit a foul on a scoring play?

— Was the goal scorer offside or not?

— Was the penalty the result of a dive or a foul?

Can a player or coach request a review?

Absolutely not. In fact, if a player “excessively” makes the box gesture to the referee, a recent change to the Laws of the Game — the rules that govern soccer — requires that the player receive a yellow card.

Who gets the last word?

All final decisions are made by the on-field referee. The VAR, FIFA stresses, is only used to assist in the decision-making process.

What can go wrong?

Plenty, despite FIFA’s best intentions. This year’s World Cup referees come from 35 countries, the assistant referees from even more, and not all of them speak the same languages. Many of those countries also do not use video review in domestic matches, which means that — even though FIFA has held several training sessions and plans even more — the system will be relatively new to many of them. Yet even in places that have it, the system does not always perform perfectly. In Germany this season, two teams had to be called back onto the field for a penalty kick because a referee removed his earpiece at halftime before a review was complete. In the Netherlands, a goal was taken off the board to belatedly award a penalty kick at the other end of the field. In a World Cup knockout game, instances like these would be FIFA’s worst nightmare. But even early critics of VAR now acknowledge the interruptions are worth it. “What we all want,” French World Cup winner Patrick Vieira said, “is less mistakes.”

Joe Ward and Andrew Das © 2018 New York Times News Service

Top Stories

Seventeen new coronavirus cases detected out of 2,465 tests

The Ministry of Health has announced that 17 new cases of the SARS-CoV-II virus were detected in Cyprus over the past 24 hours out...

Doctors stop mid-operation, dress patient in operating theatre and discharge him

Unbelievable and yet a now quintessentially Cypriot thing to happen. The incident in question is that doctors at a private hospital in Nicosia stopped...

Economic sentiment in Cyprus deteriorated slightly this September

In September 2020, economic sentiment in Cyprus deteriorated slightly as the Economic Sentiment Indicator (ESI-CypERC) decreased by 1.0 point compared to August 2020. According to...

Jiu Jitsu – Distribution for US and Canada set for November

Jiu Jitsu, the first Hollywood movie to be filmed in Cyprus under the incentive plan to promote the audiovisual industry starring Nicolas Cage, Alain...

Mainly fine weather with higher temperatures on Tuesday

Tuesday will be mainly fine with temperatures set to rise to 40°C inland, around 35°C in all coasts, and 32°C in the mountains, according...



Sheftalies, a very tasty dish from the charcoal grill, are minced meat shaped into small sausages and wrapped in “panna” (suet). Panna is a...

Spicy grilled soutzoukakia

Place all ingredients for soutzoukakia in a bowl and mix well, preferably using a food processor, until well combined. Using the mixture, form cigar-shaped...


Pork souvlaki: Put the meat and all the other ingredients in a bowl (not metal) and mix well. Cover the bowl and keep in...

Pastelli (Carob Toffee)

The nutritional sweet of Pastelli is made with the syrup of carob pods, produced by boiling their pulp until it forms a thick, sticky...